Properties range from original cottages a short walk from the sand to substantially rebuilt year-round homes and the newer Bay Beach condominium overlooking the water. Listings appear under the Crystal Beach MLS district, shown below.

Homes for sale in Bay Beach

93 active MLS® listings in and around Bay Beach.

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$519,000

384 Dovercourt Road

For Sale

4 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$499,900

42 St George Court

For Sale

9 Beds4 Baths3,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$499,000

192 Lincoln Road

For SaleVirtual tour

3 Beds2 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$698,000

633 Point Abino Road

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,550

248 Westwood Avenue

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$220,000

303 Ridge Road

For Sale

3 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$429,900

3731 Graeber Avenue

For Sale

2 Beds2 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,099,900

4945 Baywoods Road

For Rent

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,650

4058 Erie Road

For SaleVirtual tour

3 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,195,900

3765 Crystal Beach Drive

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds3 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$525,000

387 Elmwood Avenue

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,500

3819 Terrace Lane

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$104,900

3921 Victoria Road

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$144,900

0 Griffin Avenue

For SaleVideo tour

2 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$349,900

45 Conway Place

For Rent

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,280

192 Lincoln Road Unit Unit 3

For Rent

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,280

192 Lincoln Road Unit Unit 2

For Rent

5 Beds1 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,180

192 Lincoln Road Unit Front

For RentVideo tour

3 Beds3 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$3,100

26 Beachwalk Crescent

For Rent

4 Beds3 Baths2,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$3,200

78 Beach Walk Crescent

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$769,900

339 Lakewood Avenue

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds1 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$379,900

118 Lincoln Road

For Sale

8 Beds3 Baths3 ft²

Fort Erie

$899,000

231 Point Abino Road

For Sale

8 Beds3 Baths2,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$899,000

231 Point Abino Road

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds3 Baths2,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,495,000

5045 Michener Road

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,450

10 Shores Lane Unit B

For RentVideo tour

0 Beds1 Baths850 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,000

74 Queens Circle Unit #4

For Sale

2 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$599,999

3816 Crystal Beach Drive

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$999,000

532 Ridgeway Road

For SaleVideo tour

4 Beds3 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$674,999

199 Alderson Court

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,450

5b Shores Lane

For Rent

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,650

3930 Erie Road Unit 2

For Rent

2 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,850

347 Schooley Road

For SaleVideo tour

6 Beds4 Baths3,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$3,298,000

683 Point Abino Road

For Rent

2 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,100

402 Schooley Road

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$999,900

299 Cherry Hill Boulevard

For Sale

2 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$399,900

3852 Mathewson Avenue

For Rent

3 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,600

446 Cambridge Road

For Sale

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$364,900

93 Lincoln Road

For Sale

2 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$369,900

342 Helen Street

For SaleVirtual tour

3 Beds3 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$899,900

313 Beechwood Avenue

Front face of the home offers an elevated view

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$474,000

3768 Crystal Beach Drive

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$775,000

201 Hetram Court

For Sale

0 Beds5 Baths5,134 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,149,000

4064 Erie Road

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds3 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,650,000

4347 Erie Road

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$849,900

3840 Terrace Lane

For SaleVirtual tour

3 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$599,900

220 Rosewood Avenue

For Rent

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,250

370 Beechwood Avenue Unit B

For Rent

5 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,800

351 Eastwood Avenue

For Sale

2 Beds2 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$599,900

4054 Glenspring Road

For Sale

2 Beds2 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$639,900

4050 Glenspring Road

For SaleVirtual tour

3 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$759,900

4058 Glenspring Road

For SaleVirtual tour

2 Beds2 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$639,900

281 Elmwood Avenue

For Sale

3 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$489,000

373 Oakwood Avenue

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds3 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$839,900

436 Ridgeway Road

For Sale

4 Beds3 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$699,900

3806 Ryan Avenue

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$149,900

0 Westwood Avenue

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths5,742 ft²

Fort Erie

$850,000

271 Ridgeway Road

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$169,900

Vl 263 Cherrywood Avenue

For Sale

3 Beds1 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$399,900

3752 Crystal Beach Drive

For Sale

8 Beds4 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$574,900

3993 Wellington Court

For SaleVirtual tour

4 Beds3 Baths2,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$949,900

2 Beachwalk Crescent

For Sale

3 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$775,000

201 Hetram Court Unit Lot 31

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$399,900

3907 Alexandra Road

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$159,900

405 Oxford Avenue

For Sale

4 Beds2 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$569,900

357 Ridgeway Road

For Rent

0 Beds1 Baths850 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,200

74 Queens Circle Unit #2

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$159,900

3914 (Lot 240) Alexandra Road

For SaleVideo tour

3 Beds2 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$959,000

4912 Brown Road

For Sale

4 Beds5 Baths3,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,699,900

4349 Erie Road

For SaleVideo tour

5 Beds3 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$2,100,000

4337 Erie Rd Road

For SaleVirtual tour

5 Beds4 Baths3,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,999,999

725 Point Abino Road

For Sale

0 Beds1 Baths638 ft²

Fort Erie

$399,999

412 Ridgeway Road Unit B

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths1,586 ft²

Fort Erie

$549,999

412 Ridgeway Road Unit A

For Sale

0 Beds1 Baths2,231 ft²

Fort Erie

$899,000

412 Ridgeway Road Unit 1-A

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$349,999

0 Beechwood Avenue

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,400 ft²

Fort Erie

$6,000

3823 Terrace Lane Unit 405

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,600 ft²

Fort Erie

$7,000

3823 Terrace Lane N/A Unit 303

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths2,000 ft²

Fort Erie

$9,500

3823 Terrace Lane Unit 202

For Rent

2 Beds2 Baths1,800 ft²

Fort Erie

$9,000

3823 Terrace Lane N/A Unit 201

For Rent

0 Beds3 Baths6,027 ft²

Fort Erie

$25

3823 Terrace Lane N/A Unit Suite 101

For Sale

3 Beds3 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$760,000

3805 Ryan Avenue

For SaleVirtual tour

5 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$679,900

404 Lakewood Avenue

For SaleVideo tour

2 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$359,900

263 Maplewood Avenue

For SaleVideo tour

4 Beds4 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$650,000

35 Comet Lane

For SaleVirtual tour

3 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,189,000

3711 Crystal Beach Drive

For Sale

1 Beds1 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$349,900

291 Eastwood Avenue

For Sale

4 Beds1 Baths1,100 ft²

Fort Erie

$299,888

315 Eastwood Avenue

For Rent

4 Beds2 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$3,500

231 Rosewood Avenue

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths

Fort Erie

$1,395,000

3879 Rebstock Road

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths4,200 ft²

Fort Erie

$1,395,000

3879 Rebstock Road

For Sale

0 Beds0 Baths700 ft²

Fort Erie

$230,000

Lot 194 Mathewson Avenue

Welcome to 212 Lincoln Road West, Crystal Beach

For Sale

2 Beds1 Baths1,500 ft²

Fort Erie

$320,000

212 Lincoln Road

Recently sold in Bay Beach

Recent sales help you understand what homes in Bay Beach actually go for.

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Nov 6th 2026

$2,300

3 bd 2 ba 700 sqft

248 Lincoln Road, Fort Erie, ON

X14081432 • MICHAEL ST.JEAN REALTY INC.

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Nov 4th 2026

$325,000

1 bd 1 ba 700 sqft

354 Elmwood Avenue, Fort Erie, ON

X14084348 • KELLER WILLIAMS REFERRED URBAN REALTY

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 29th 2026

$665,900

3 bd 4 ba 1,500 sqft

3 Cyclone Lane, Fort Erie, ON

X13652742 • ROYAL LEPAGE NRC REALTY

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 27th 2026

$280,000

2 bd 1 ba 1,100 sqft

42 Cambridge Road, Fort Erie, ON

X14028078 • SOLID ROCK REALTY

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 23rd 2026

$2,500

3 bd 2 ba 1,100 sqft

41 Haun Road, Fort Erie, ON

X13724434 • ROYAL LEPAGE NRC REALTY

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 14th 2026

$1,650

1 bd 1 ba 1,500 sqft

52 Queens Circle Unit 2, Fort Erie, ON

X13749226 • ROYAL LEPAGE NRC REALTY

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 13th 2026

$499,000

1 bd 1 ba 700 sqft

4974 Brown Road, Fort Erie, ON

X13793324 • REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 9th 2026

$369,900

3 bd 3 ba 1,500 sqft

3824 Roxborough Avenue, Fort Erie, ON

X13574874 • RE/MAX ESCARPMENT REALTY INC.

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Oct 9th 2026

$449,900

2 bd 1 ba 700 sqft

374 Ridgeway Road, Fort Erie, ON

X13797746 • FLYNN REAL ESTATE INC.

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Sep 30th 2026

$699,500

3 bd 1 ba 700 sqft

436 ASHWOOD Avenue, Fort Erie, ON

X13615054 • RE/MAX NIAGARA REALTY LTD, BROKERAGE

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Sep 26th 2026

$2,400

3 bd 2 ba 1,100 sqft

399 Elmwood Avenue, Fort Erie, ON

X13638664 • REVEL Realty Inc., Brokerage

Join or Sign In · See photos & sold data

Real estate boards require a verified account

Sold • Sep 21st 2026

$2,600

3 bd 1 ba 1,100 sqft

Address available upon request, Fort Erie, ON

X13705348 • BOSLEY REAL ESTATE LTD.,

Bay Beach Homes for Sale

Homes for sale in Bay Beach

384 Dovercourt Road

42 St George Court

192 Lincoln Road

633 Point Abino Road

248 Westwood Avenue

303 Ridge Road

3731 Graeber Avenue

4945 Baywoods Road

4058 Erie Road

3765 Crystal Beach Drive

387 Elmwood Avenue

3819 Terrace Lane

3921 Victoria Road

0 Griffin Avenue

45 Conway Place

192 Lincoln Road Unit Unit 3

192 Lincoln Road Unit Unit 2

192 Lincoln Road Unit Front

26 Beachwalk Crescent

78 Beach Walk Crescent

339 Lakewood Avenue

118 Lincoln Road

231 Point Abino Road

231 Point Abino Road

5045 Michener Road

10 Shores Lane Unit B

74 Queens Circle Unit #4

3816 Crystal Beach Drive

532 Ridgeway Road

199 Alderson Court

5b Shores Lane

3930 Erie Road Unit 2

347 Schooley Road

683 Point Abino Road

402 Schooley Road

299 Cherry Hill Boulevard

3852 Mathewson Avenue

446 Cambridge Road

93 Lincoln Road

342 Helen Street

313 Beechwood Avenue

3768 Crystal Beach Drive

201 Hetram Court

4064 Erie Road

4347 Erie Road

3840 Terrace Lane

220 Rosewood Avenue

370 Beechwood Avenue Unit B

351 Eastwood Avenue

4054 Glenspring Road

4050 Glenspring Road

4058 Glenspring Road

281 Elmwood Avenue

373 Oakwood Avenue

436 Ridgeway Road

3806 Ryan Avenue

0 Westwood Avenue

271 Ridgeway Road

Vl 263 Cherrywood Avenue

3752 Crystal Beach Drive

3993 Wellington Court

2 Beachwalk Crescent

201 Hetram Court Unit Lot 31

3907 Alexandra Road

405 Oxford Avenue

357 Ridgeway Road

74 Queens Circle Unit #2

3914 (Lot 240) Alexandra Road

4912 Brown Road

4349 Erie Road

4337 Erie Rd Road

725 Point Abino Road

412 Ridgeway Road Unit B

412 Ridgeway Road Unit A

412 Ridgeway Road Unit 1-A

0 Beechwood Avenue

3823 Terrace Lane Unit 405

3823 Terrace Lane N/A Unit 303