DAVIDS&DELAAT
5159 Shirley Avenue
+36 more

5159 Shirley Avenue, Niagara Falls, ON

$649,900
For Sale

L2E 5C3

Listed October 1, 2026

4Bedrooms
2Bathrooms
1,100Sq. Ft.

About this property

Privacy, Space, & Pride-of-Ownership... Tucked away on a quiet corner in Niagara Falls' private Northend, this sprawling brick bungalow is the kind of home buyers hope to find-but rarely do. Peaceful, private and beautifully cared for, it offers the space to live comfortably, entertain effortlessly and create memories for years to come. Imagine pulling into your driveway, parking for 6+, without worrying about side neighbours. Discover beautiful, pristine hardwood floors, inviting living spaces plus LR gas fireplace framed in angel brick, creating warmth and character throughout the home. The kitchen is both practical and thoughtfully equipped, with a built-in cooktop, dishwasher, water purifier, gas rough-in, 2025 frige and dinette area. The dining room, with California shutters, provides the perfect setting, from casual family dinners to holiday gatherings. Then the feature that may quickly become your favourite - the L-shaped three-season sunroom. With 2 sets of sliding glass doors and access to the interlock BBQ patio, it creates a wonderful connection between the home and outdoors. Picture morning coffee, afternoon conversations and summer evenings with friends. Finished downstairs, the home surprises you with even more space. A huge 25-foot tiled laundry room, 4th bedroom, and a huge family room with its own gas fireplace provide room for hobbies, recreation, family time. Best of all, many of the big-ticket updates have been taken care of: 2025 furnace and A/C, 2025 water softener, 2026 chlorine removal tank and an owned 2024 hot water tank. This isn't simply a house that's been maintained, it's a home that's been loved. Every detail reflects genuine pride of ownership. If you've been waiting for a home that offers privacy without isolation, space without compromise, and character with modern updates, your search may have just ended. Discover the hidden gem that is 5159 Shirley Ave. You may walk in as a Buyer and walk out imagining yourself living there!

Features

FireplaceAir ConditioningBasement

Property Details

Listing

MLS® NumberX13847112
StatusFor Sale
ListedOctober 1, 2026
Listing TypeFor Sale
Listing OfficeCentury 21 Heritage House LTD

Property

Property TypeSingle Family Home
Interior Size1,100 ft²
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2

Location

Community211 - Cherrywood
CityNiagara Falls
ProvinceON
Postal CodeL2E 5C3

Taxes & Financials

Asking Price$649,900
Property Taxes (2026)$4,057/yr

Cost of Ownership Calculator

What it could cost each month to own 5159 Shirley Avenue — mortgage, property taxes, fees, insurance, utilities and upkeep. Change any number to match your situation.

Your mortgage

$129,980 · Minimum $39,990

Use the rate your lender or broker quotes you.

Monthly costs

From the listing (2026 tax bill).

Leave at $0 if there isn't one.

Typical for this kind of home.

Hydro, heating, water and sewer.

About 1% of the price a year, set aside.

One-time costs

A typical estimate — your lawyer will confirm.

Estimated monthly cost of ownership

$4,210/mo

About $50,520 a year

  • $2,875
  • $338
  • Home insurance$125
  • Utilities$330
  • Maintenance & repairs$542

Cash needed to close

Down payment (20%)
$129,980
Ontario land transfer tax
$9,473
Legal fees, title insurance & inspectionEstimate
$2,500
Total
$141,953

Estimates only — not a mortgage approval, quote or tax advice. Payments assume a fixed rate compounded semi-annually; minimum down payments, mortgage insurance and land transfer tax follow current CMHC and Ontario rules. Insurance, utilities and upkeep are typical figures for the area. Your lender, lawyer and insurer will confirm your exact costs.

Location

Regional Crime Severity Index

2025 Statistics Canada Police-Service Reference

Niagara Regional Police Service (Niagara Region)

Released July 22, 2026 · Base: 2006 Canada = 100

Niagara Falls is policed by the Niagara Regional Police Service. Covers all 12 Niagara Region municipalities as one combined police jurisdiction — not reported separately by town, neighbourhood or street.

2025 Overall CSI
53.84
−8.65% vs. 2024 (2024: 58.94)
2025 Violent CSI
69.83
−11.70% vs. 2024
2025 Non-violent CSI
47.91
−6.77% vs. 2024
Ontario (2025 provincial)
57.17
Violent 74.91 · Non-violent 50.56

How the index works: Statistics Canada's Crime Severity Index tracks both the volume and relative court-sentencing weight of police-reported incidents per 100,000 population, indexed to Canada in 2006 = 100, and is published once a year by police service rather than for individual neighbourhoods or properties.

Source: Statistics Canada, Table 35-10-0188-01 (Crime severity index and weighted clearance rates, police services in Ontario), released July 22, 2026. Reproduced and distributed on an "as is" basis with the permission of Statistics Canada. Table 35-10-0188-01 · Statistics Canada Open Licence.

Similar Properties Nearby

View all →

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about 5159 Shirley Avenue and its surrounding neighbourhood.

What are the key details of 5159 Shirley Avenue?

5159 Shirley Avenue, Niagara Falls, ON L2E 5C3 (MLS® X13847112) is a single family home featuring 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 1,100 sq ft, currently listed for sale at $649,900.

What are the property taxes or monthly fees for 5159 Shirley Avenue?

The MLS® listing for 5159 Shirley Avenue, Niagara Falls, ON L2E 5C3 lists reported annual property taxes of $4,057 (2026).

How can I book a private showing for 5159 Shirley Avenue?

Use the Request a Showing form on this page or call Davids & DeLaat at (289) 272-5329 to arrange an in-person tour or ask questions about 5159 Shirley Avenue, Niagara Falls, ON L2E 5C3.

Last Updated: October 1, 2026

Listing Office: Century 21 Heritage House LTD

This listing content is owned and licensed by REALTOR® members of The Canadian Real Estate Association. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service®, and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.